Can Lawyers Bill for AI Time? What New York’s AI Billing Guidance Means for Your Firm

New York's new AI ethics guidance says lawyers can bill for the time they spend working with AI, but not for the hours it saves. Here's what that means for hourly billing, AI tool costs, and why flat fees can turn AI efficiency into margin.

Can Lawyers Bill for AI Time? What New York’s AI Billing Guidance Means for Your Firm

New York's new AI ethics guidance says lawyers can bill for the time they spend working with AI, but not for the hours it saves. Here's what that means for hourly billing, AI tool costs, and why flat fees can turn AI efficiency into margin.

Law firm engagement letter on a desk with the Statue of Liberty in the background
Breaking News for Law Firms, SMB Team

Short answer: lawyers who bill by the hour can bill for the time they actually spend working with AI, including writing prompts and checking the output. They cannot bill for the hours the AI saved them. That is the position the New York State Bar Association took when its House of Delegates approved new AI ethics guidelines on October 31, 2026.

For firm owners, the bigger story is pricing. If AI turns a six hour task into a two hour task and you bill by the hour, you just gave away four hours of revenue. The firms that come out ahead will be the ones that rethink how they price the work.

What New York’s AI billing guidance says

The billing rule is Guideline No. 5A in NYSBA’s Legal Ethics Guidelines for Lawyers’ Use of Artificial Intelligence. It ties back to New York Rule of Professional Conduct 1.5, which prohibits excessive fees. The ABA Journal covered the guidance here. Five points matter most:

  • Hourly billing: You may bill only for time actually spent, including time spent writing inputs and reviewing, verifying and revising AI output. You may not bill for time the work would have taken without AI.
  • Learning the tool: Time spent getting generally familiar with an AI tool is not billable. Reasonable time adapting a tool to a specific matter can be.
  • Tool costs: The general cost of AI subscriptions is ordinarily overhead. It can be billed as a disbursement only when it is reasonably allocable to the client’s matter, disclosed to the client and reasonable in amount.
  • Flat and contingent fees: These remain subject to Rule 1.5, but efficiency gains alone do not require you to reduce a non hourly fee.
  • Disclosure: The basis of the fee and any AI related charges must be communicated to the client, in writing where required.

Keep the jurisdiction in mind. These are bar association guidelines written for New York lawyers. Other states have issued their own ethics opinions, and your state bar rules still apply wherever you practice. Talk with ethics counsel before you change how you bill.

Why hourly billing turns AI savings into lost revenue

Hourly billing ties revenue to time. The whole point of AI is to reduce time. Put those together and every efficiency gain shows up as a smaller invoice.

Picture a family law firm that drafts discovery responses. The work used to take six hours. With AI drafting and attorney review, it takes two. Under hourly billing, the firm now bills two hours. The client is happy. The firm paid for the AI tool, generally cannot pass that subscription through as a disbursement, and lost four billable hours.

Multiply that across every attorney and paralegal on the team and AI starts to look like a cost center instead of a profit driver.

Not sure what AI is doing to your margins? SMB Team’s FCFO team helps law firm owners model pricing, tool costs and profit by case type. Talk to our team.

Alternative fee arrangements turn AI efficiency into margin

With a flat fee, the client pays for the outcome, not the hours. When AI shortens the work, the fee holds and the time saved becomes margin. New York’s guidance says efficiency alone does not require you to reduce a non hourly fee, as long as the fee is still reasonable under all of the Rule 1.5 factors.

That shift changes the conversation on all sides:

  • Clients get predictable pricing and know the cost up front.
  • AI tool costs get built into the price instead of debated as line items on an invoice.
  • The firm gets rewarded for working efficiently instead of penalized for it.

Flat fees fit best on well scoped, repeatable work, such as uncontested divorces, misdemeanor defense and estate plans. Matters with unpredictable scope are harder to price, and hourly or hybrid models may still make sense there. The ABA’s overview of alternative fee arrangements is a useful primer on the options.

How to price AI assisted work without guessing

Moving to flat fees without the numbers is just a different way to lose money. Before you change your law firm pricing, model these five things:

  • Scope: What the fee covers and what triggers additional fees.
  • Real time on desk: Attorney and staff hours with AI in the workflow, including review time.
  • Tool costs: Subscriptions and any per matter AI costs, allocated across your caseload.
  • Margin target: The profit you need per matter after labor and overhead.
  • Disclosure: How the fee and any AI related expenses are explained in your engagement letter.

Then test the new price against a batch of recently closed matters before you roll it out.

Ready to rethink your pricing?

AI will keep shrinking the time legal work takes. Firms that bill by the hour will feel that as lost revenue. Firms that price the outcome will feel it as margin. SMB Team’s Fractional CFO team helps law firm owners model fixed fees, tool costs and profitability so the switch makes money instead of costing it.

Start My Pricing Conversation

Frequently asked questions

Can lawyers bill for time spent using AI?

Under New York’s guidance, lawyers who bill hourly can bill for time actually spent, including writing prompts and reviewing, verifying and revising AI output. They cannot bill for time the AI saved.

Can lawyers charge clients for AI tools?

General AI subscriptions are ordinarily overhead. A charge that is reasonably allocable to a specific matter can be billed if it is disclosed and reasonable.

Do flat fees have to drop when a firm uses AI?

Not because of efficiency alone, according to the New York guidance. The fee still cannot be excessive under Rule 1.5.

Does New York’s AI billing guidance apply in other states?

It is written for New York lawyers. Check your own state’s rules and ethics opinions, because several states have addressed AI billing in their own way.

Scroll to Top